Live the Questions

Words of Torah, funny anecdotes about my students, rants about education policy, and observations on politics, progressive Judaism, activism, and culture will all make appearances on this blog. Each post will end with a question for the reader; please respond if you feel moved.

Sunday, December 17, 2006

What do Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik and Arlo Guthrie have in common?

D’var Torah—Vayeshev 2006

Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik, a leading 20th century theologian, commented that last week’s torah portion, this portion, and next week’s portion all prominently feature a mysterious “ish” or man. Last week in vayishlach we read about Jacob’s nighttime battle with a nameless ish. Next week, Joseph’s brothers, unaware of his true identity as they beg him for food, will refer to him as “the man.” This week, we read about another nameless “ish.” Jacob sends Joseph on his fatal errand to check on his brothers in Shchem, where Jacob thinks they are pasturing their flocks. When Joseph arrives in Shchem, they are nowhere to be found. While Joseph is wandering the fields searching, a man finds him. This conversation ensues:

The Man: What are you looking for?
Joseph: I’m looking for my brothers. Please tell me where they took their flocks.
The Man: They left. I heard them say that they were going to Dotan.

I would add to Rabbi Soloveichik’s drash that in this week’s parsha we also have a mysterious isha or woman, in addition to the ish. In order to obtain justice for herself and to continue her dead husband’s line, Tamar disguises herself as a cult prostitute and sits by the roadside. The Torah makes a point of telling us that when Judah sleeps with her, he has no idea who she is. When Judah’s friend returns with payment for the “isha,” she has disappeared. They are dumbfounded until Tamar appears in court and reveals her true identity.

So what are the connections between these figures?

First, they all represent encounters with an Other, a being or person assumed to be distant from the self, family, and community. In two of the cases, those of Joseph and of Tamar, the mysterious Other turns out to be a member of the family, an intimate part of the self. In the case of the ish who Jacob wrestles, we never really know his true identity—was he an angel? A manifestation of Jacob’s own psyche? Here we have the theme of the person who is seemingly an Other but is revealed to be intimately connected with the self.

Second, in the case of the ish and isha in this portion, both of the interactions are perfunctory encounters in which the person is objectified. The man in the field at Shchem is just that—some guy who gave Joseph directions. To Judah, Tamar is just some kedesha, a cult prostitute, he meets along the roadside. The ish or isha is just an object, someone of use to the main character, but, at first glance, not significant as an individual.

However, these two incidents are intimately connected to some of the grandest and most crucial events in Jewish history—the Exodus from Egypt and the establishment of the Davidic Kingdom. Peretz, one of the twins born from the union of Judah and Tamar, becomes one of the ancestors of King David, and therefore of the messiah as well; according to traditional accounts, the messiah will be “ben Partzi.” So Tamar’s actions result in the birth of King David and the establishment of the Israelite kingdom.

How does some guy in the field giving directions relate to the Exodus from Egypt? Well, to explain that I’ll have to retell a dvar torah that I heard from one of the great rabbis of our generation, Arlo Guthrie, at a concert. Guthrie pointed out that the Exodus really all leads back to that man standing in the field. Had Joseph given up on finding his brothers and just headed back to Jacob, the story of the Jewish people would have been very different. Joseph never would have been sold into slavery by his brothers, never would have gone down to Egypt, never would have brought his family there, and thus the Jews would never have been enslaved in order to be redeemed. And, as Guthrie said at the concert, it was all due to one man standing in a field saying, “They went that way.” Joseph himself emphasizes that every step was part of God’s plan; when his brothers apologize to him for selling him into slavery, he tells them, “Even though you meant harm to me, God meant it for good, to achieve his present end, the survival of many people.”

Traditional commentaries pick up on the importance of this figure. Rashi, the 11th century French commentator, states that the man is actually the angel Gabriel, while Midrash Rabbah on Genesis says that Joseph actually encountered three angels, based on the fact that the word ish is repeated three times in that passage, thus drawing a connection between the men who announce Isaac’s birth to Abraham and Sarah and Joseph’s encounter in the field.

What is an angel anyway, and why is it important to the rabbis to designate that this man standing in the field is actually an angel? First, the rabbis are responding to some curious details in the text. Note that Joseph does not ask the man “can you tell me where my brothers are?” but rather “tell me where my brothers are” and that the man does not have to ask who Joseph’s brothers are or what they look like—he knows. That seems to indicate some supernatural funky stuff going on.

However, I also think that if we consider the connection between all of the mysterious Others in these parshiot—all of the “ish”es and the isha, that in their insistence on identifying this man in the field as an angel, the rabbis are actually saying something about the possibility for humans to be messengers of God and instruments for bringing about God’s will.

The most common Biblical term for angel is malach, which comes from the root for messenger—a messenger of God. So by definition, an angel is someone acting as God’s messenger. Here’s where Rabbi Guthrie comes in. That random guy in the field, nameless and mildly helpful, actually ends up having a dramatic effect on the destiny of the Jewish people. His small gesture of kindness, giving directions to a lost stranger, becomes a key part of a chain of events that results in the fulfillment of God’s plan.

It often seems Pollyanna-ish and overly idealistic to believe that we have the power to be a force for positive change in the world. This story does not deny the fact that we are all tiny cogs within our society, and that our ability to make direct, sweeping change is limited. It does not overestimate our power. Instead, it reminds us that the long-term, distant consequences of our actions may be more powerful and more significant than we could ever dream.

This story also pushes us to recognize the innate possibility for power in those people we encounter in our daily lives—the checkout clerk, the person next to us on the subway. It cautions us not to see them merely in relation to ourselves, but rather as potential world-changers and great deed-dooers.

Here we have two seemingly random encounters with a nameless other, and both turn out to be crucial events in determining the history of the Jewish people. In both cases, the Other is actually a malach, a messenger of God, an instrument of God’s will in the world. So here’s a double blessing for this week: First, may we be able to recognize that the person, the ish or isha, who we encounter in a seemingly meaningless, day-to-day way, may actually be a malach. Secondly, may we be able to understand the ways in which we ourselves, despite our seeming insignificance, can be malachim.

64 Comments:

  • At 1:14 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    That was beautiful, thank you for posting. The connection between the "isha" who turns out to be Tamar, and the "ish" who turns out to be Yosef, is very poignant. We are more connected to strangers than we realize.

     
  • At 12:22 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    i *love* the idea of checkout clerk as potential great-deed-doer. so many people wear so many hats, it is an impossible task for us to intuit all that one has and may do. so, i think you are right to demand that we all see everyone as having infinite potential to fundamentally alter our universe.

     
  • At 6:08 PM, Blogger Patriot Fan said…

    This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

     
  • At 3:35 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    I found this site using [url=http://google.com]google.com[/url] And i want to thank you for your work. You have done really very good site. Great work, great site! Thank you!

    Sorry for offtopic

     
  • At 3:12 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    No prescription dutas Get trandate Pharmacy carafate Sale viagra soft 25mg arcoxia No prescription relafen

     
  • At 7:37 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    I just discovered the website who writes about
    many
    home business ideas

    If you want to know more here it is
    home based business opportunity
    www.home-businessreviews.com

     
  • At 11:30 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=http://www.chf4kids.org/news/]Viagra buy now[/url]

     
  • At 3:06 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=http://digg.com/health/Viagra_Health_manual_Viagra_without_prescription/]buy viagra without prescription[/url]

     
  • At 4:22 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=http://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/b6hcv/viagra_without_prescription_erectile_dysfunction/]Buy Viagra Without Prescription[/url]

     
  • At 4:14 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Helo ! Forex - Outwork чашкой кофе получают удовлетворение от работы стала независимой, достаточно зарегистрироваться forex [url=http://foxfox.ifxworld.com/]forex[/url]

     
  • At 4:16 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    [url=http://sexrolikov.net.ua/tags/%EF%E0%F5%F3%F7%F3%FE/]пахучую[/url] Смотреть порно онлайн : [url=http://sexrolikov.net.ua/tags/%EF%E0%F5%F3%F7%F3%FE/]пахучую[/url] , это все смотри

     
  • At 5:56 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy cheap viagra viagra vs cialis price - order viagra online with no prescription

     
  • At 7:39 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    generic viagra viagra online 150 mg - viagra online jersey

     
  • At 4:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    viagra 100mg viagra professional online pharmacy - buy viagra us over counter

     
  • At 5:58 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    viagra 50mg viagra from us - viagra for women stories

     
  • At 3:51 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    generic viagra generic viagra in us - viagra 50mg dosage

     
  • At 10:44 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    order viagra cheap viagra prices - viagra dosage when to take

     
  • At 3:16 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol online tramadol online legal - buy tramadol online with cod

     
  • At 4:45 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy soma online buy soma online paypal - soma whole foods

     
  • At 9:43 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy soma online soma 350 mg pills - online somatotype test

     
  • At 11:32 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy soma somo 650 - soma drug wiki

     
  • At 4:40 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy soma buy soma online with credit card - soma printable coupons 2012

     
  • At 8:30 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy soma discount coupon for soma - soma the strokes

     
  • At 1:29 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    soma price radiohead soma san diego - soma yahoo answers

     
  • At 4:41 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy soma klonopin soma drug interaction - soma bras houston

     
  • At 1:02 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    soma online buy soma online - soma san diego official website

     
  • At 3:49 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    tramadol online cod how to buy tramadol online - tramadol hcl nih

     
  • At 5:22 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy cialis online cialis dosage 60 mg - generic cialis non-prescription

     
  • At 1:51 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol cash on delivery tramadol online - why can you buy tramadol online

     
  • At 9:17 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy cialis online cialis tadalafil 20mg reviews - cialis vision side effects

     
  • At 12:39 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol online tramadol and high - tramadol 50 mg buy online

     
  • At 2:34 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    xanax online meclizine xanax drug interactions - xanax experience

     
  • At 5:06 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    generic xanax much do 1mg xanax go - xanax side effects blurred vision

     
  • At 6:50 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    order xanax xanax birth control pills - xanax online prescription

     
  • At 1:43 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol tramadol hcl zydol 50mg - legal buy tramadol online us

     
  • At 4:09 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol can you buy tramadol usa - tramadol zofran interaction

     
  • At 5:49 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    xanax online pharmacy many grams xanax overdose - xanax bars like

     
  • At 8:32 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy xanax online cod generic xanax capsule - lorazepam generic xanax

     
  • At 12:57 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol order tramadol online mastercard - buy tramadol cod online

     
  • At 7:37 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol effects of tramadol high - tramadol no prescription mastercard

     
  • At 8:29 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy carisoprodol order carisoprodol no prescription - carisoprodol 350 mg recreation

     
  • At 1:45 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    best buy tramadol tramadol hcl zoloft - tramadol hcl 50mg 627

     
  • At 12:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy cialis online can you buy cialis online in usa - cialis 10mg price

     
  • At 5:28 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    cialis online low price cialis - order cialis no prescription online

     
  • At 10:38 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy cialis cheap buy cheap cialis no prescription - cialis online legale

     
  • At 10:52 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    http://landvoicelearning.com/#63987 tramadol hcl drug test - tramadol 50mg buy online

     
  • At 7:53 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    http://landvoicelearning.com/#23561 buy tramadol online us pharmacy - tramadol withdrawal hell

     
  • At 4:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    tramadol 100 generic name of tramadol - tramadol vs hydrocodone addiction

     
  • At 6:44 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol no prescription pharmacy - tramadol no prescription free shipping

     
  • At 4:46 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy klonopin online 2mg klonopin lot - klonopin overdose how much is too much

     
  • At 8:31 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    aaa!!! Topamax Cost - topamax weight loss http://www.topamaxbestonline.net/#order-topamax, [url=http://www.topamaxbestonline.net/#order-topamax]Topamax Online[/url]

     
  • At 5:42 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    03 generic prednisone online - generic prednisolone http://www.prednisoneonlinerx.net/index.html, [url=http://www.prednisoneonlinerx.net/index.html]order prednisone [/url]

     
  • At 7:47 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol cod fedex tramadol 50 mg is used to treat - tramadol withdrawal vertigo

     
  • At 1:39 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol online can take 3 50 mg tramadol - buy tramadol without a script

     
  • At 7:32 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    4, lasix online no prescription - furosemide no prescription http://www.lasixordernow.net/, [url=http://www.lasixordernow.net/]lasix price [/url]

     
  • At 10:45 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    tramadol without prescription tramadol hcl high erowid - tramadol with valium high

     
  • At 8:43 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    tramadol no prescription tramadol for cats overdose - buy tramadol online no prescription mastercard

     
  • At 1:42 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    buy tramadol buytramadol.ca - tramadol addiction usa

     
  • At 8:35 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol 200mg - cheap generic tramadol

     
  • At 11:26 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    all, order isotretinoin - order accutane online http://www.freeyogablog.com/#order-accutane-online , [url=http://www.freeyogablog.com/#buy-generic-accutane-no-prescription ]buy generic accutane no prescription [/url]

     
  • At 1:13 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    carisoprodol 350 mg getting high carisoprodol - carisoprodol with vicodin

     
  • At 11:13 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol 350 mg no prescription - carisoprodol dosage erowid

     
  • At 2:21 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    http://southcarolinaaccidentattorney.com/#90864 carisoprodol usp 350 mg - carisoprodol soma sun

     
  • At 3:07 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    ooo!!! [url=http://www.homeworkhelpinstant.com/assignment.html]online assignment [/url] online assignment help - online assignment submission - order assignment http://www.homeworkhelpinstant.com/assignment.html [url=http://www.provigilbetterprice.com/]provigil online pharmacy no prescription [/url] buy generic provigil online - generic provigil online - order provigil online no prescription http://www.provigilbetterprice.com/ [url=http://www.homeworkhelpinstant.com/assignment.html]order assignment help [/url] order assignment online - order assignment solution - order assignments http://www.homeworkhelpinstant.com/assignment.html

     

Post a Comment

<< Home